The World Is Their Parish: Can The United Methodist Church Survive?

This post originally appeared on The Huffington Post Religion.

In a post this week, Taylor Burton-Edwards, Director of Worship Resources of the General Board of Discipleship — a national organization of the United Methodist Church charged with helping local churches by “equipping world changing disciples” — asked what “missional Methodists” should do in the face of our church’s newest digital report card toy — dashboards.

To see an example of this nifty gadget click here.

Notice you can find out weekly information about churches that have the biggest gain or loss in membership and attendance, baptisms and professions of faith (you can even click on a link to those naughty churches that have not turned in their weekly numbers yet … tisk, tisk).

In the end, Burton-Edwards, although he criticizes this form of documenting “maintenance discipleship”, advises pastors to fill out the forms and then go beyond them … (I mean he does work for the church after all and some conferences actually take the data into consideration when assigning pastors to particular churches) So, my pastor friends out there, if they ask for your Saturdays — four days a month — to fill out paperwork, give them at least five days. Turn in monthly reports, in addition to your weekly ones! Detail the spiritual growth and document the amazing evidence of discipleship … go beyond … go beyond.

I’m sure that there is something good that comes from all that reporting, but in general, as I shared in a previous post, I am pretty unimpressed with how the church I love, the United Methodist Church, is going beyond its majority-white, status-quo supporting self to minister to … the world.

John Wesley, founder of the Methodist movement, was quoted as saying: “The world is my parish.” He did not say “the people that show up to this particular building on a Sunday are my parish.” The United Methodist Church has become a cushy institution, banking on performance measures kept by fancy gadget dials to help save it from the fate towards which all mainline denominations seem to be heading — slow death.

And yet, I believe there is hope for the United Methodist Church.

One such locus of hope centers in on the phenomenon of “church plants”. Although I do not believe this move toward church planting is the ‘silver bullet’ that will save our denomination, I do know of at least three church plant congregations that take seriously Wesley’s charge to make the world their parish:

Mosaic Brooklyn Park, Minnesota

Hope.Gate.Way Portland, Maine

Urban Village Church Chicago, Illinois

For lack of space, I will detail the one I know best — Mosaic in Brooklyn Park, Minnesota. Mosaic’s pastor, Rev. Rachel McIver Morey, was my roommate in seminary. She was the one who always finished every single page of reading before class and proofread all of my last-minute writing assignments (the ones she had already finished the day before). She read a chapter of the Bible every morning (i.e. she had read it in its entirety over 5 times). She made plans and kept them; she was efficient and would have probably made whatever conference leadership extremely happy with her dashboard-dial-reporting skills.

But then at least two things happened … first she was called to plant a multicultural church (where none had existed before) and second she became a mother.

It is this second thing, motherhood that has prepared her for the first … church planting, and especially church planting a multicultural church. There is something about rocking a colicky baby for hours on end that gives a person a new outlook on life. Not only is not being in control of a situation 100 percent tangible (I literally watched Rachel rock her son for an hour while he writhed with stomach pain she could not fix), but the only thing left to do is be present in the midst of it. The peace that exuded from her being as she rocked her screaming baby was nothing like the anxiety-ridden seminary intern who had to make sure every aspect of the church service went off without a hitch.

Rachel and her husband, Jerad, have discovered that multicultural church planting is a colicky baby whose occasional smiles are all the reward they will see at first. It is is not a well behaved child that adheres exactly to all the developmental milestones all the books say should be there. God’s peace came to Rachel in the rocking chair, and it is what gives Rachel and the Mosaic team the strength to do the street level ministry with real people that they are called to do.

Unlike a normal church appointment, Rachel and other church planters must build up their congregations from scratch. They build up networks of interested people (this means a lot of coffee dates, covered lunches, community activities, etc), raise funds (preach in the pulpits of churches who take up offerings, reach out to potential donors, etc.) and launch four preview services. Whether or not Rachel continues in this project, in part, depends on the amount of people that attend these preview services. Here is a description of their most recent preview service:

On Saturday, March 12th, Mosaic gathered at Odyssey Academy in Brooklyn Park to make sandwiches for Simpson shelter — which, with all hands on deck, ended up taking twenty minutes even with a break to go buy more bread! — and collect canned goods for our local food shelf. At five o’clock, we chimed the gong and began worship. Our worship was a new format using table conversation and fellowship alongside music from Paraguay, the U.S., and Indonesia. We closed with a celebration of communion and each had a bologna sandwich in communion and community with the Simpson Shelter guests who would be eating them for lunch the next day.

Not your typical Sunday Service … Praise God. It’s not that I hate liturgy (in fact I worship in an Episcopal church at the moment, which is much more formal than most United Methodist congregations), but I love that Mosaic takes the liturgy out into the world.

In the book of 1st Samuel chapter 16 begins, “The Lord said to Samuel, ‘How long will you grieve over Saul?’ I have rejected him from being king over Israel. Fill your horn with oil and set out; I will send you to Jesse the Bethlehemite, for I have provided for myself a king among his sons.” In this text, the prophet Samuel has been ordered by God to go anoint a new king, while the old king, whom Samuel had also anointed, is still around. Samuel goes to do what he is told, has all of the sons of Jesse pass before him, but not one is the king God has chosen. Samuel asks “Are all your sons here?” And Jesse replies … “There remains the yet the youngest, but he is keeping the sheep.” This youngest son, David, would eventually become the most revered and loved king of Israel.

The United Methodist Church needs to look out among these young pastors — the ones who are out tending the sheep. They, not the ones best at keeping score on dashboard dials, make the world their parish and change the world through discipleship. They could be a part of a new era of Methodism … so my Methodist brothers and sisters, how long will you grieve over the loss of your past glory? God has rejected it and moved on … and we should too.

5 thoughts on “The World Is Their Parish: Can The United Methodist Church Survive?”

  1. Thank you for giving me image of the mother rocking her colicky child. It is such a beautiful one to meditate on, and helpful for any kind of ministry.

    It is difficult to have the kind of faith and trust to let die that in the church which needs to die, to know that what we think is necessary may not be necessary after all (an area I have been reflecting a lot on lately).

    I love your use of concrete examples and biblical text to craft a point simply yet elegantly. Your message is evocative, and quite valid for all mainstream churches.

    1. Dear Kathryn Ray,

      Thank you for your response.

      I think it is not only extremely hard to let die in the church what needs to die (for those who are willing to engage in such a process), but there are people invested, due to their own stuff (whether it be anxiety, pride or what they really believe is right, etc.) in making sure the church does not get out of their control. So giving over control to God by giving up power and giving to those who traditionally have not had power (i.e. non-white people for example) in the UMC not something most in power are willing to do. Often they proclaim diversity, but practice tokenism. This is exemplified in most “multicultural” churches that claim to be so because there is more than one race or ethnic group in attendance on a given Sunday, but if you look at who is actually running the committees and making decisions about money… it usually turns out to be a monochrome type of group.

      I hope bringing scripture into such debates will reorient them in some way through the lens of scripture… in this case reorienting our concepts of success and especially how to attain it…

      Thanks again for your comments!
      Peace,
      Kelly

  2. Finally some time for reading State of Formation….and once again enjoying your thoughts, Kelly. I am the first director of a start-up non-profit within a University, and I have a list of rules for church planters that hangs on my wall. There’s so much that is true to any new venture–the courage and tenacity it takes to enter into the uncertain, work with the best forces that exist, and trust something wonderful to emerge. I’m very excited about what is emerging on the margins, even as I’m one who worships in a quite traditional place. Fortunately, change has a way of finding us, even as we resist, hide, turn away, etc. You’ve helped us to have some images and empowerment from scripture and from life to prepare to ride the waves of change, working with life as it is rather than how we would have it be. Thank you.

    Jennifer

  3. Jennifer,

    If you have a chance, could you share the rules for church planting that you mentioned?

    Thanks

    Kathryn

    1. Kathryn, here goes! With regret, I can no longer find the original document, so cannot reference fully. The title is “American Baptist Churches USA, Church Renewal & Organizational Development, Suggestions for New Church Starts”.

      1. Identify your top three goals and make progress on each one everyday. [This is one I try to think about fairly consistently.]

      2. Listen to those whom you are trying to reach (constantly) and make changes based upon what you hear.

      3. Start with enough seed money to take you well into your next sources of income.

      4. Recruit administrative help immediately. Even if it is minimal or volunteer–don’t try to do all of this yourself even on day one.

      5. Make sure that your family is squarely behind/beside you.

      6. Have a web presence and strategy sooner rather than later. [Demonstrates that this list is a bit dated….I’d hope everyone would start with this now!]

      7. Plan and prepare for anything that could go wrong. Expect Murphy to show up on a regular basis.

      8. The first help you hire should be in your area of greatest personal need. The complementary skills will set an excellent pattern and you will not be tempted to micromanage if they know more than you do!

      9. Never stop thinking like an entrepreneur. You will not plateau until you stop doing what got you to your current level, so don’t stop.

      10. Focus on everyday results. Deliver one cup at a time. [This has been key to our success as a start-up just celebrating five years of truly significant success–small moments of impact have accumulated to something quite grand!]

      11. Develop strategic partnerships.

      12. Feed your passion and it will grow. Never lose sight of your first love.

Comments are closed.